(If you do not see a RENEW button, please select a plan
and enter any code you may have received in a renewal notice online or in print.)
If you have ANY questions at all, please contact support@claviercompanion.com
7 minutes reading time (1407 words)

Why don't you come out of the pantry? Is left-handed piano music anything more than just a historical curiosity?

pantry
Why should a pianist with both hands in perfectly working order bother to devote their time and energy to study—not to mention perform—compositions or arrangements for the left hand alone? Is there any value in exposing oneself to that obscure genre? And what if you actually have some inclination towards it, but are not ready for J.S. Bach's Chaconne or Ravel's Piano Concerto for the Left Hand? Allow me to share some of my observations from years of studying and arranging piano music for the left hand.

Raymond Lewenthal provides a hilarious depiction of the almost Cinderella-like role of the left hand at the piano. In his compilation entitled Piano Music for One Hand, he describes the left hand as the one responsible for all the household chores. Chief among them is "supplying accompaniments or oom-pah-pahs."When suddenly the left hand is called upon to play a more virtuosic passage it is as if it got "called out of the pantry and (was) expected to appear as the belle of the ball."2 Comical as this image may be, there is a lot of truth in it. Here is the first point: working on left-handed repertoire may provide a chance for microscopic scrutiny as you never allowed yourself when dealing with standard, two-handed repertoire. Side effect? Your left hand will be out of the pantry for good, executing its passages on a par with the right hand.

Now, let us pause for a moment to consider briefly how composers expanded pianistic textures throughout the centuries. The chief trend was to adapt orchestral or other instrumental techniques for the keyboard, or rather adapt the hand and condition it to executing these on the piano. This is how wide-reaching, violinistic figurations and orchestral tremolos found their way into piano repertoire. 

For the pianist it is a great technical workout to play such figurations with one hand. An even greater challenge, that of splitting the five fingers into multiple voices, teaches a lot about the art of polyphonic playing. But there is yet another "bonus" level in the left-handed repertoire. It comes with having to jump from register to register, between different strains of musical narration, polyphonic voices, prolonging one in our mind's ear, while executing another, and then physically returning to that original line we left just a few notes back.

Here is where the whole pianistic paradigm shifts. The horizontal, multi-layered thinking gives way to somewhat of a more vertical approach. Playing with two hands, the activity can be visually described as two parallel strains:


Similar musical effect with left hand only would be visually summarized as follows:

To understand the latter example in real life, please compare measures 3-6 of Chopin's Prelude in G Major, Op. 28, No. 3, in its original version (Excerpt 1a) with its left-handed arrangement (Excerpt 1b). The
need for quick register changes will be immediately apparent.

Excerpt 1a: Prelude in G Major, Op. 28, No. 3, by Frédéric Chopin, mm. 3-6.
Excerpt 1b: Left-hand alone arrangement of Chopin’s Prelude in G Major, Op. 28, No. 3, by Igor Iwanek, mm. 3-6.


It is a well-documented fact that a favorite pastime of Johannes Brahms was to play J.S. Bach's compositions for solo violin, as well as those for unaccompanied violoncello. 

Brahms played these at the piano with his left hand alone. It provided a great sightreading practice and an opportunity to commune with some of the most logical and eloquent music ever written. It simultaneously engaged many facets of Brahms's personality: the pianist, the composer, the analytical thinker, and the romantic.

Let us follow Brahms's lead for a moment. Is there anything unusual to learn from Bach regarding the polyphony of a single line? Why should pianists care? Isn't there enough of great polyphony written originally for the keyboard anyway? Of course there is. However, being faced with an intricate single line is a fantastic learning experience in its own right. All of a sudden, the means are limited; there is no accompaniment to fall back on. Such
an environment increases our alertness and enhances the incisive and sharp tool from our brain's toolkit required for tackling keyboard polyphony. In the Excerpt 2a you see measures 35-44
from Bach's Corrente (Violin Partita in B Minor). Reimagine the same music as multiple voices overlapping and unfolding simultaneously. Now study each voice as a separate entity. Afterward, learn to sing each line against the other; you can sing one voice and play other(s) (Excerpt 2b).

Excerpt 2a: Violin Partita in B Minor, BWV 1002, Corrente, by J. S. Bach, mm. 35-44.
Excerpt 2b: Left-hand alone arrangement of J. S. Bach’s Corrente from the B Minor Violin Partita, Corrente, by Igor Iwanek, mm. 35-44.


Working this way, you learn to investigate the music under the microscope and Bach's genius unfolds right there in front of your eyes and ears. When you come back to playing the music as one line, your understanding of the music and its underlying structure will never be the same. I teach a lot of students, many of whom are non-pianists, and we direct music this way. Curiously, after such a session, without having spoken a word about  instrumental technique per se, their playing changes dramatically. Issues that seemed to have originated as technical shortcomings suddenly dissolve.

Of course, one has to admit that we are dealing with the medium of one-handed playing, which obviously has its limitations. Because of these limitations, at times important musical threads have to be altered to maintain the integrity of the composition as a whole. Consider, for example, the opening of the Fugue in G Minor, BWV 1001 (Excerpt 3a). Measures 1-6 are perfectly playable by the left hand alone. However, the pianist will encounter many awkward jumps on the way, unless he is equipped with a giant left hand. If you consider the nature of this fugue and its subject, more military than sensual in its content, thriving better in the faster metronomic realms, this music becomes very awkward to render with one hand. So are we ready then to compromise the text or the tempo and therefore the spirit of the piece? In Excerpt 3b, the arrangement ties some of the subject notes over and thus avoids awkward jumps (Excerpt 3b). It is up to your sense of musical taste and blasphemy quotient "(how dare you tamper with Bach's notes)" to decide what is acceptable. Having experimented with both approaches, I lean towards Excerpt 3b and its apparent text violation.

Excerpt 3a: Fugue in G Minor, BWV 1001, by J. S. Bach, mm. 1-6
Excerpt 3b: Left-hand alone arrangement of J. S. Bach’s Fugue in G Minor, BWV 1001, by Igor Iwanek mm. 1-6

On the other side of the spectrum, Franz Liszt famously advocated, "demand the impossible in order to find out all that is possible." Along the same lines, in order to test the limits of human resilience, Leopold Godowsky, known as the Buddha of the piano, arranged many of Chopin's études for left hand alone. Shortly after finishing that project he wrote, "if it is possible to assign to the left hand alone the work done usually by two
hands simultaneously, what vistas are opened to future composers, were this attainment extended to both hands!." We know what happened after. Fortunately (or not) for us mortals, Godowsky's approach proved to be the
apex of virtuosity, elevated on the eternal pedestal, revered, but heir-less. 

When executing wide chords with the left hand we actually run into the aesthetics of interpretation. Even if we simply try to make a passage playable, the way in which we choose to break the chord or whether to place the melody or the bass on the strong part of the beat is an act of interpreting the music. By adapting the work to the physical limits of a single hand, we highlight certain voices and hide others. In order to do this we need to have a complete understanding of the work in question, so that our choices are musically valid and supported by the text itself.

Instead of a summary of the proposed arguments in favor of the left-handed repertoire, let me leave you with an arrangement of Bach's Sarabande. (Example 4). It is a short, beautifully emotional, almost romantically expressive work, full of wide-spanning chords made up of polyphonic lines underneath. The arrangement imposes some hierarchy as far as voices are concerned but leaves you complete freedom regarding dynamic shadings of the phrases. In my effort not to over interpret Bach's work I leave as much as possible in its original, unedited form.

Example 4: Left-hand alone arrangement of J. S. Bach’s Sarabande in B Minor, BWV 1002, by Igor Iwanek.

1 Lewenthal, R. (1986). Piano Music for One Hand: A Collection of Studies, Exercises and Pieces. New York: G. Schirmer.

2 Ibid. 

You have to be a member to access this content.

Please login and subscribe to a plan if you have not done so.

February 24
March/April 2018: The Winds of Change
 

Comments

Already Registered? Login Here
No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment

By accepting you will be accessing a service provided by a third-party external to https://www.ClavierCompanion.com/

About Piano Magazine

Piano Magazine is the leading resource for pianists, piano teachers, and piano enthusiasts. We bring you informative, interesting, and inspiring ideas on all aspects of piano teaching, learning, and performing. The official name of Clavier Companion magazine was changed to Piano Magazine in 2019.

Follow us on

Terms of use

Have Questions?

We are happy to help.

Editorial questions? This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
Advertising questions? This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
Subscription questions? This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
Technical questions? This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
Cron Job Starts